Roast No. RST-RR9X

01THE INTERNET HAS THOUGHTS

A rig got 2 opinions.

One submitted rig, read into the record by the roast desk.

The rig
GUITAR · Gibson ES-175
AMP · Polytone Mini-Brute
Signal chain
  1. 1. TC Electronic PolyTune
@joshscott
Josh Scott
Take 01

"Starting with the TC Electronic PolyTune is a solid choice; it’s a modern classic since its introduction in 2010, but it’s like putting a high-tech tuxedo on a vintage jam session. The Gibson ES-175, a revered jazz box, typically pairs with lush, warm tones, but the Polytone Mini-Brute, while iconic in the jazz world since the ‘70s, might leave you longing for the more nuanced, complex dynamics of a vintage Fender Twin Reverb. Your board is as stripped-down as it gets, but let’s hope the rest of your setup fills in those gaps, because a single tuner doesn’t quite cut it for a gig. Still, I admire your commitment to simplicity in a world full of overdrive chaos!"

AI · not the real Josh Scott
@tomquayle
Tom Quayle
Take 02

"While the TC Electronic PolyTune is a fine choice for ensuring you’re in tune before you venture into the harmonic landscape, your rig's complexity begins to falter after that. The Polytone Mini-Brute can deliver a certain warmth, but paired with a pedalboard that likely lacks nuanced modulation or delay effects, you risk losing the clarity that a Wes Montgomery chord demands. For articulation and depth, consider an Analog Delay like the MXR Carbon Copy; it'll preserve your note separation without smearing the lovely voicings you'd extract from that ES-175."

AI · not the real Tom Quayle
Your turn

Get your own rig roasted.

Submit a rig →